perm filename NEGATE[4,KMC]1 blob
sn#092499 filedate 1974-03-20 generic text, type T, neo UTF8
00100 BEFORE, DURING AND AFTER-THOUGHTS ON NEGATION
00200
00300
00400 REMEMBERING WHAT LOGICIANS SAY ABOUT NOT CONFUSING THE
00500 NEGATION OF A SET WITH ITS COMPLIMENT, I STILL BELIEVE THAT "I DON'T
00600 LIKE HIM" HAS AS ITS PREFERRED MEANING "I DISLIKE HIM" RATHER THAN "I
00700 AM NEUTRAL OR INDIFFERENT TO HIM".
00800 BUT NOTICE THAT IN SOME SEMANTIC SPACE, OPPOSITES ARE MUCH
00900 CLOSER THAN ANY OTHER PAIRINGS BECAUSE THEY SHARE A DIMENSION. THUS
01000 IN ATTACKING SOMETHING ONE REALLY COUNTERSUPPORTS IT.
01100 HEISENBERG SAID THAT THE OPPOSITE OF A SHALLOW TRUTH IS FALSE
01200 BUT THE OPPOSITE OF A DEEP TRUTH IS ALSO TRUE. THUS MATTER AND
01300 ANTI-MATTER EXIST AS TRUE. OSCAR WILDE AND GBS CONSCIOUSLY EXPLOITED
01400 OUR BELIEFS THAT OPPOSITES (OR NEGATIONS) ARE TRUE. ("EVERY MAN KILLS
01500 THE THING HE LOVES", ETC.).
01600 AMONG OTHER ARGUMENTS, THE REASON I CAN'T BELIEVE THOSE
01700 "TALKING" CHIMPS POSSESS LANGUAGE IS THAT THEY NEVER USE NEGATIONS
01800 EXCEPT IN THE SENSE OF "I DON'T WANT". THE OTHER TWO SENSES OF
01900 NEGATION, I.E. NONEXISTENCE AND DENIAL, ARE NEVER USED BY THEM.
02000 NOTICE HUMANS DO NOT DENY SOMETHING WHICH IS NOT ASSERTED.
02100 FREUD HAD AN AMUSING SUGGESTION REGARDING NEGATIONS OF DREAM
02200 REPORTS. WHEN SOMEONE SAYS "I HAD A DREAM LAST NIGHT ABOUT A WOMAN.
02300 IT WAS NOT MY MOTHER", ONE SHOULD ASSUME THE IDEA UNDERLYING THE
02400 VISUAL IMAGE OF THE WOMAN ACTUALLY INVOLVED HIS MOTHER. IF ONE
02500 INVARIABLY TAKES THE POSITION THAT ALL NEGATIONS ARE DENIALS, SOME
02600 FUNNY THINGS CAN HAPPEN.
02700 IN YOUR PRAGMATIC IMPLICATIONS OR INFERENCES, WOULDN'T IT BE
02800 MORE PRECISE TO SAY THAT IF AN AGENT CAUSES X TO MOVE, THEN HE
02900 DESIRES OR WANTS THE RESULTANT SITUATION BUT HE DOES NOT NECESSARILY
03000 "LIKE" IT. THIS ALLOWS AN AGENT TO PRODUCE NEGATIVELY VALUED
03100 SITUATIONS IN ORDER TO COPE WITH SOMETHING.
03200 GOOD TALK. IT INSPIRED JOHN TO WANT TO SAY SOMETHING AND BE
03300 BARKED AT ALSO.